Prompted by a current class and some one on one discussion, I’m pondering evangelism, sharing the Gospel, seeking the lost, being missional, winning the lost, et al, In this post I want to share some observations and pose some questions, which will likely require additional posts. Here we go, in no particular order:
It is my perception there is very little disagreement among most Christians that sharing our faith is important, if not mandatory, as disciples of Christ. Assuming I am correct, why then, does the subject elicit personal resistance? (I am no exception).
Very few people I know are reluctant to share good news , experiences or products in their lives. We often do so spontaneously, even to strangers on occasion. That being the case, why then, if the Gospel is really good news in our lives, don’t we share that news? ( I can feel the guilt creeping in)
I am under the impression that, generally, evangelistic efforts are not highly successful. (Please don’t ask how much one soul is worth) I do believe, in the past decade or so, there has been a resurgence of emphasis on evangelism, particularly in church plants and para-church ministries.
I wonder how much our reluctance to evangelize is related to the current polarized and divisive culture where disagreement often devolves into angry conflict? THe old adage “you don’t talk about religion and politics” has become an inviolable rule.
Similarly, to what extent does the prevailing cultural ethos of tolerance, acceptance, individual rights, etc restrain our engagement with unbelievers?
Are progressive Christians the problem? “The progressive impulse toward tolerance and inclusion, along with a post-modern stance on truth, leaves progressive Christians in an awkward position in regards to evangelism, sharing the gospel with non-believers. Evangelism smacks of judgementalism, I’m right and you are wrong. Worse, evangelism can tend toward colonialism, the history of white missionaries being sent to save dark pagan savages.” (Beck)
Could uncompromising, evangelism zealots be the problem? “ Compelled by an urgency of doom and gloom… turn or burn.. fear, fueled by “you can”t go to heaven alone”; sharing the Gospel becomes an ultimatum to the human will. Choose Christ and live or deny Christ and go to hell.
How important is our motivation for sharing the Gospel? Does it really matter why if souls are being saved?
Do church growth strategies foster the idea that evangelism is the responsibility of staff, primarily the preaching pastor?
You have probably have had other thoughts and/or questions. My list is not intended to be exhaustive. I am certain that sharing the Gospel should be a priority for all believers. I am equally sure that current efforts are not yielding abundant fruit.
What I believe is critically important is that we understand the reality we face and re-examine our theological, ecclesiastical, spiritual and culture assumptions to begin transformational change. Hopefully, this conversation can move us in that direction.
Questions and comments are welcome.