Menu Close

A Few Thoughts

Thomas Merton wrote, “A man knows when he has found his vocation when he stops thinking about how to live and begins to live.”


I just say what everyone else is thinking. 

There’s a reason people don’t always say what they’re thinking. Most of us have thoughts that scare even ourselves. We also often have initial intense and emotional reactions that we know aren’t how we will feel in a few minutes. And we have the capacity to be forgiving, given some time to think things through. Most importantly, we have the intelligence to know the gap between what we think and what we say is like knee cartilage that keeps the knee moving smoothly rather than bones grinding against each other. We think before we speak because we’re mature enough to understand consequences and humble enough to know our initial thoughts can be tainted by unflattering emotions.

When an uncomfortable truth needs to be told, we should convey it with compassion. The goal is to help people see the truth so they can change, not bully them so they retreat even further.

Kareem Abdul Jabbar


Categorical thinking

…categorical thinking makes it harder to see people as individuals. Better to see a person first as a unique individual, with their own distinctive way of observing and being in the world, and then to see them also as a member of historic groups, and then to understand the way they fit into existing status and social structures. To see a person well, you’ve got to see them in all three ways.

David Brooks


Old Man thinking

I mowed the lawn today, and after doing so
I sat down and had a cold beer.
The day was really quite beautiful, and the drink facilitated some deep thinking.
My wife walked by and asked me what I was doing,
and I said, “Nothing.”
The reason I said “nothing” instead of saying “just thinking” is because she then would have asked, “About what?”
At that point I would have had to explain that men are deep thinkers about various topics, which would lead to other questions.
Finally I pondered an age old question: Is giving birth more painful than getting kicked in the nuts?
Women always maintain that giving birth is way more painful than a guy getting kicked in the nuts, but how could they know?
Well, after another beer, and some more heavy deductive thinking, I have come up with an answer to that question.
Getting kicked in the nuts is more painful than having a baby, and even though I obviously couldn’t really know, here is the reason for my conclusion:
A year or so after giving birth, a woman will often say, “It might be nice to have another child.”
But you never hear a guy say, “You know, I think I would like another kick in the nuts.”
I rest my case.
Time for another beer. Then maybe a nap.
Credit : Thewani Dewmi


Comedian Larry Miller once observed, “If [women] knew what [men] were really thinking, they’d never stop slapping us.”


Overthinking

Somewhere between overthinking and underthinking is responsible and responsive thinking. As a Christian who tries to be a thinking Christian I’ve always taken seriously the discipleship of the intellect, the Christian mind, or as Anselm called it “faith seeking understanding.”

Christian faithfulness is the result of cumulative choices, some of them anguished and even conflicted. But gradually, choices become consistent, behaviour begins to reflect character, and character reveals the characteristics of the follower of Jesus. We inhabit the values and principles of the Kingdom of God. When that happens much of the thinking is done, and the decisions we make as Christians become habit. That’s not to say following Jesus becomes merely a habit; it is to say that as those called to participate in the life of Christ, through the transforming grace of Christ crucified and risen, enabled by the energising of love of God, we are drawn into the communion of the Holy Spirit and into participation in the mission of the Triune God of love. 

So neither overthinking or underthinking, we are called to know and live in the mind of Christ, to offer ourselves as living sacrifices which is our reasonable worship, to love God with all our heart, and soul and body, and yes, our minds.

Jim Gordon


Nonduality thinking

 nonduality: a way of thinking, acting, reconciling, boundary-crossing, and bridge-building based on inner experience of God and God’s Spirit moving in the world. We’re not throwing out our rational mind, but we’re adding nondual, mystical, contemplative consciousness. When we have both, we’re able to see more broadly, deeply, wisely, and lovingly. We can collaborate on creative solutions to today’s injustices.

…read the mystics with an attitude of simple mindfulness, the insights and practices they share can equip us with a deep and embracing peace, even in the presence of the many kinds of limitation and suffering that life offers us. From such contact with the deep rivers of grace, we can live our lives from a place of nonjudgment, forgiveness, love, and a quiet contentment with the ordinariness of our lives—knowing now that it is not ordinary at all!

Richard Rohr


Cognitive Overload

“Studies of cognitive overload suggest that the real problem is that people who are thinking about rules actually have diminished capacity to think about solving problems.”

Phillip K Smith


Thinking like a golfer

Bad shot? We tell ourselves it has to be the balls or the clubs, which is why we’ll purchase a dozen balls for $50 despite knowing we’re likely to lose at least two or three a round because we’re not as good as we think we are, or we’ll spend thousands on irons because we believe they will make our shots travel longer and straighter without the required practice time. Poor drive? Has to be the driver, which is why we’ll spend hundreds to replace the one we purchased the year before.

Jim Trotter


Fundamentalism will continue to live in the body of those who are being healed from fundamentalism.

Fundamentalism is a pattern of thinking and relating; it is the belief that a certain person or group of people know the right way to think, act, talk, relate, believe, and engage with the world and that those who do not subscribe to this worldview are lesser than, dangerous, pitied, hard to relate to, or to be avoided.

The process of healing, which is not a moment in time, but a lifelong journey, entails the willingness to embrace choice. The choice to leave fundamentalism, to deconstruct one’s past, and to reconstruct one’s Christian faith “can feel all-consuming.” The journey is worth it.


Humility

Humility is not thinking lowly of yourself; it’s an accurate perception of yourself. It is the ability to cast aside illusions and vanities and see life as it really is.

David Brooks


Thinking in different ways

They are also learning to think in different ways. The psychologist Jerome Bruner argued that there are two modes of thinking: paradigmatic mode and narrative mode. Put simply, paradigmatic mode is making the case for something; narrative mode is telling stories.

Most of us spend our careers getting good at paradigmatic mode—making arguments, creating PowerPoint presentations, putting together strategy memos, writing legal briefs. But in plotting the next chapter of their lives, the fellows need to update their story, which requires going into narrative mode. They have to weave a tale of how they grew and changed, going back to childhood.


Thinking

Most of us think we are our thinking, yet almost all thinking is compulsive, repetitive, and habitual. We are forever writing our inner commentaries on everything, commentaries that always reach the same practiced conclusions. That is why all forms of meditation and contemplation teach a way of quieting this compulsively driven and unconsciously programmed mind.  

Richard Rohr


Evolutionary Thinking

Evolutionary thinking is, for me, the very core concept of faith, where we trust that God alone steers this mysterious universe, where there is clearly much hidden from us and much still before us—and where “eye has not seen, and ear has not heard, and the human heart has not conceived, what God has prepared for those who love God” (1 Corinthians 2:9).

Evolutionary thinking is contemplative thinking. It leaves the full field of the future in God’s hands and agrees to humbly hold the present with what it only tentatively knows for sure. Evolutionary thinking agrees to knowing and not knowing simultaneously. It sends us on a trajectory, where the ride is itself the destination, and the goal is never clearly in sight. To stay on the ride, to trust the trajectory, to know it is moving, and moving somewhere always better, is just another way to describe faith. We are all in evolution all the time, it seems to me.  

Richard Rohr


Thinking

There are a lot of people who struggle with God simply because they are tenacious in following the theological thread to the logical and bitter end. A lot of us think our way into faith problems. It’s not that we think too much, just that we insist that people face up to the logical assumptions and consequences of their beliefs.

Richard Beck


Thinking about an infinite God

…if there is a God great enough to merit your anger over the suffering you witness or endure, then there is a God great enough to have reasons for allowing it that you can’t detect. It is not logical to believe in an infinite God and still be convinced that you can tally the sums of good and evil as he does, or to grow angry that he doesn’t always see things your way.

Timothy Keller


thinking about life as a journey

…reminds me to stop trying to set up camp and call it home. It allows me to see life as a process, with completion somewhere down the road. Thus I am freed from feeling like a failure when things are not finished, and hopeful that they will be as my journey comes to its end.I want adventure, and this reminds me that I am living in it. Life is not a problem to be solved, it is an adventure to be lived.

John Eldridge 


Smart People

Thinking that people somewhere else are special because they do stuff that humans everywhere do is one of the weirder mistakes a lot of smart people make. 

Jonah Goldberg 


Multitasking, in short, is not only not thinking, it impairs your ability to think. Thinking means concentrating on one thing long enough to develop an idea about it. Not learning other people’s ideas, or memorizing a body of information, however much those may sometimes be useful. Developing your own ideas. In short, thinking for yourself. You simply cannot do that in bursts of 20 seconds at a time, constantly interrupted by Facebook messages or Twitter tweets, or fiddling with your iPod, or watching something on YouTube.

Just thinking..

Still on the Journey

THE CHURCH – Losing the Battle for Attention (part 3)

… abandoning an obsession for growth and what that might look like.

Previous posts can be read HERE.

Previously posts contend churches which embrace church growth strategy and become obsessed with growth are winning the battle for attention but are headed in the wrong direction; though open to question, I am confident obsession with growth is a diversion from the Church’s purpose 1The purpose of the church is a subject worthy of its own discussion. Rachel Held Evans –Searching for Sunday is helpful:
The purpose of the church, and of the sacraments, is to give the world a glimpse of the kingdom, to point in its direction. When we put a kingdom-spin on ordinary things–water, wine, leadership, marriage, friendship, feasting, sickness, forgiveness–we see that they can be holy, they can point us to something greater than ourselves, a fantastic mystery that brings meaning to everything. We make something sacramental when we make it like the kingdom. Marriage is sacramental when it is characterized by mutual love and submission. A meal is sacramental when the rich and poor, powerful and marginalized, sinners and saints share equal status around the table. A local church is sacramental when it is a place where the last are first and the first are last and those who hunger and thirst are fed. And the church universal is sacramental when it knows no geographic boundaries, no political parties, no single language or culture, and when it advances not through power and might, but through acts of love, joy, and peace and missions of mercy, kindness, and humility.
and it is important to consider abandoning obsession for growth and what might happen as a result.

I have no illusion abandoning obsession for growth would be easy, the cost is high.

“When we unplugged from the high-octane, entrepreneurial, pragmatic, success-driven, attractional model of church growth, our church was plunged into a decade-long roller-coaster ride of excessive (at times) introspection, organizational upheaval, uncertainty, plummeting attendance and fractured relationships.”

— Renovation of the Church: What Happens When a Seeker Church Discovers Spiritual Formation by Kent Carlson, Mike Lueken
https://a.co/jdRMLLe

The cost of doing nothing is infinitely higher.

“A moderated religion is as good for us as no religion at all—and more amusing.” 

Screwtape Letters – C.S. Lewis

Abandoning an obsession for growth is not insignificant. Success, plus material and emotional sunk costs are high bars. Churches who adopt church growth strategy and become obsessed with growth; like fish, have no awareness that they are swimming in water. Such a radical decision requires painful soul-searching and the Holy Spirit’s work.

ALERT: What follows is derived from numerous resources and my imagination.

FROM:

TO:

Leadership/Administration

  • Leadership is relieved of the relentless, never satisfied monster of bigness.
  • Staff and resources committed to programs and facilities become available for ministry/missions.
  • Leadership/ staff meetings focus on spiritual concerns rather than growth issues.
  • Corporate leadership paradigm replaced with leadership by service.
  • Management by objective replaced by continuous improvement. Values over metics 
  • Kingdom strategy replaces marketing strategies/ tactics

Praise and Worship

  • Performance gives way to authentic praise and worship
  • Cacophony becomes symphonic, producing collective effervescence.
  • Celebration is no longer exclusive, space is provided for grief and lament 
  • Church demonstrates openly its hope and gladness; while honoring the gospel’s call for holiness, piety, repentance, and solemnity.
  • Communion moves from the margin to the center

Preaching

  • Focus becomes “One Another”, building community rather than soliciting contributions to fund facilities and increase staff. 
  • Preaching the Word, the person and work of Jesus, is prioritized. 
  • Promoting growth gives way to proclaiming the Kingdom of God
  • The preacher becomes a “midwife of the word” in the event of preaching.

Discipleship

  • Discipleship shifts from transactional to transformational.
  • No longer a manufacturing plant, assembling and repairing machines and robots. It is a conversion, confession, repentance, reconciliation, forgiveness, and sanctification center, where flawed people place their trust in Christ, gather to know and love him better, and learn to love others as he has designed.
  • Discipleship is designed to send people back into daily life where the real Christian life is lived.

 Evangelism/ Outreach

  • Thrust of evangelism changes from ‘come to church’ to ‘come to Jesus’.
  • Outreach focused on building a diverse rather than homogenous community
  • Faith sharing involves more conversations than lectures.
  • Evangelism is not more important than how others are treated.
  • Evangelism happens when the reality of God’s love and saving grace is revealed through spiritual conversation with authentic whole-life disciples.

Language/ Vocabulary

  • I becomes WE
  • My church becomes Our church 
  • Kingdom narrative replaces Ideographic rhetoric.
  • Meaningful talking, attentive listening, and profound thinking emerge
  • Sacred words- “Sacred words are containers that carry information about deep and often invisible realities. They help us describe, albeit imperfectly, what we believe. Words allow us to whisper encouragement over the God-loved downtrodden, and we use them to pray and to preach and to praise. 
  • Language about the virtues Christians call the fruit of the Spirit—words like love, patience, gentleness, and faithfulness.

What is the “church?” 

The church is God’s instrument through which his Holy Spirit moves and expresses his love, proclaiming the ‘good news’ that Jesus is redeeming the world to come under his kingdom. WE are the church! The church is God continuing to live and work in this world through us. When we see the church that way, the focus moves off of ourselves and we break out of the consumer mindset. 
Erwin McManus

STILL ON THE JOURNEY

  • 1
    The purpose of the church is a subject worthy of its own discussion. Rachel Held Evans –Searching for Sunday is helpful:
    The purpose of the church, and of the sacraments, is to give the world a glimpse of the kingdom, to point in its direction. When we put a kingdom-spin on ordinary things–water, wine, leadership, marriage, friendship, feasting, sickness, forgiveness–we see that they can be holy, they can point us to something greater than ourselves, a fantastic mystery that brings meaning to everything. We make something sacramental when we make it like the kingdom. Marriage is sacramental when it is characterized by mutual love and submission. A meal is sacramental when the rich and poor, powerful and marginalized, sinners and saints share equal status around the table. A local church is sacramental when it is a place where the last are first and the first are last and those who hunger and thirst are fed. And the church universal is sacramental when it knows no geographic boundaries, no political parties, no single language or culture, and when it advances not through power and might, but through acts of love, joy, and peace and missions of mercy, kindness, and humility.

Tyranny- Cost Benefit Analysis

Convinced a “Jesus said” argument against tyranny is not persuasive, even for Christians. This post will attempt to persuade using cost/benefit analysis; “fighting fire with fire”.

It has occurred to me that the word tyranny may be off-putting for some, thinking it personally irrelevant. Let me disabuse that idea… as fallen humans we all desire to be god — tyrants, abusing power, control and authority to exercise our will over others.


BENEFIT

Tyranny is EFFECTIVE
Tyranny always works. If desired results are change, movement, attention, fear, chaos, confusion, compliance, obedience, conformity; abusive exercise of power and control is the answer.
It satisfies,
“something has to be done”
“better to do something than nothing”
“righteous anger”
“need to control”
It is justifiable,
“the end justifies means”
“this hurts me more than you’
“only because I love you”
“sometimes you just have to shake things up”

The calm voice at the helm says, “Make it so…” and with it, the mantra of modernity is invoked. The philosophy that governs our culture is rooted in violence, the ability to make things happen and to control the outcome. It is a deeply factual belief. We can indeed make things happen, and, in a limited way, control their outcome.
Fr Stephen Freeman

…we soon discover (and have proven it time and again) that our ability to control is quite limited. Many, many unforeseeable consequences flow from every action.

Perhaps consequences are not so much unforeseeable as they are hidden, masked by rationalization —
It didn’t work as well as I thought, but just think how bad it would have been otherwise..”

COST

Tyranny inherently establishes upper limits. Demands are quantified to control and punish. Tyrants always calculate demands against risk of failure, rebellion or worse. Assuming achieving the demand is a possibility, threats, coercion, violence, fear will accomplish the goal. Unless additional pressure is applied, no goal will ever be exceeded. Because tyrants assume others incompetent and weak, they have no comprehension of the potential of what a person can do, mentally or physically. Imposition of tyranny will never experience full potential of human capacity.

“Tyranny is the deliberate removal of nuance.” –Albert Maysles
Albert meant that tyranny was an attempt to remove thoughtfulness, creativity, and self-expression from society (often through physical oppression) at the expense of originality. Nuance is simply subtle differences in interpretation or expression, and tyranny is almost uniformly obsessed with uniformity 1https://quotesexplained.com/tyranny-is-the-deliberate-removal-of-nuance-albert-maysles/

A subset of human capacity, nuance —virtue, thoughtfulness, creativity, and self-expression—, is what makes us uniquely human. Its loss is tyranny’s highest cost, our humanity.
Tyranny is the ethos of powers and principalities, a Faustian bargain that costs our souls.

Jesus said, “…you are not to be like that…”

ITS UP TO YOU, CALCULATE THE COST / BENEFIT…

STILL ON THE JOURNEY

  • 1
    https://quotesexplained.com/tyranny-is-the-deliberate-removal-of-nuance-albert-maysles/

A Few Thoughts

The moral to be drawn from “Chicken Little” depends on the version.
Where there is a “happy ending”, the moral is not to be a “Chicken” but to have courage.
In other versions where the birds are eaten by the fox, the fable is interpreted as a warning not to believe everything one is told.


Perceptions

Our perceptions are shaped by prior knowledge, beliefs, assumptions, and expectations. We impose meaning upon the world, and while that meaning brings some things into view it blinds us a well. You’ve heard the old adage, “seeing is believing.” Well, it’s also true that “believing is seeing.” Perception is more top-down than bottom-up.

Richard Beck


Unhappiness

When it comes to decreasing happiness — or growing unhappiness — the United States has dropped to its lowest-ever position at 24, having previously peaked at 11th place in 2012. The report states that the number of people dining alone in the United States has increased 53% over the past two decades.

https://apnews.com/article/world-happiness-report-ranking-finland-afghanistan-us-b41c1712448762d98fe9e4f80233c15f


What could possibly go wrong?

South Dakota Republican Gov. Larry Rhoden signed bills into law last week allowing concealed pistols in bars and on public college campuses. Rhoden justified this law with the usual slogans that defies basic logic: “One of my favorite things about South Dakota is how much we respect freedom — especially our Second Amendment freedom.” 


Sacrifice

Mostly, references to sacrifice are inaccurate virtue signaling. Not at all what Dr. King meant—or most religions and philosophies—but rather some twisted version that makes people feel virtuous while still being self-serving. I hear contestants on competitive reality shows like Survivor or Top Chef tearfully complain about how much they sacrificed to be there, leaving family behind, quitting jobs, etc. Same with elite athletes who’ve just won a championship crowing about all they’ve given up. Not going to proms or vacations so they could practice their sport.

That isn’t sacrifice! 

It’s substituting one experience for another that they think will benefit them more. For them, the end goal is success, so nothing that is done in the pursuit of personal aggrandizement is a sacrifice, merely a beneficial choice. It’s a clear indication of how clueless people are about the true meaning of sacrifice when they are a contestant on The Bachelor looking for sympathy for all their “sacrifices” to come on a TV show, live in a mansion, and become minimally famous for achieving nothing. It’s just as disingenuous to sign a $10 million contract with a sports team and proclaim all the sacrifices you and your family made to get here.

I’m especially put off by people who demand sacrifice from others—usually in the form of money—in order to enrich themselves. Evangelical preachers who fly around on their private jets and politicians who hawk products and beg for donations while sitting on millions or billions of dollars aren’t saviors—they’re what we need to be saved from. FYI: MLK’s net worth at the time of his assassination in 1968 was about $50,000.

True sacrifice is when one chooses to give up something precious in order to do something that doesn’t directly benefit them but does directly benefit others. 

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar


Spiritual Striving

I am always leery when asked about various spiritual undertakings. Whether it’s a rule of prayer or a rule of fasting, the true struggle is never found in doing what is extraordinary. It is, rather, the very difficult matter of enduring what is given to us. God, in His providence, allows us all that is necessary for our salvation. Grace is primarily found within the ordinary faithfulness of our life.

Fr Stephen Freeman


We become what we worship.

If we worship power, we become instruments of vindictiveness.
If we worship money, we become instruments of theft.
If we worship pleasure, we become instruments of sex.
We become what we worship.
What we worship becomes obvious in how we live.
We become what we worship.
We don’t worship our nation, but it beckons us to give it our worship.
We don’t worship our nation, but we care about it.
We worship Christ, and when we worship Christ we turn away from the rubbish and loss and sewer crud of vindictiveness.
We worship Christ, and when we do we gaze upon a completely different kind of life.
Worshiping Christ leads to a life of grace.
Worshiping Christ leads to a life of forgiveness.
Worshiping Christ leads to a life of love.
Worshiping Christ leads to a life of peace.
Worshiping Christ leads to a life of justice.
We become what we worship.

Scot McKnight


The Challenge

The greatest challenge of the day is: how to bring about a revolution of the heart, a revolution which has to start with each one of us. When we begin to take the lowest place, to wash the feet of others, to love our brothers and sisters with that burning love, that passion, which led to the cross, then we can truly say, “Now I have begun.”

Dorothy Day


Islands of Sanity

When even two or three of us gather in the name of truth, honesty, and love, in the name of courage, compassion, and kindness, we find ourselves feeling joined by another presence—the presence of Christ, the way, the truth, and the life. We listen to one another with compassion and curiosity. We speak to one another with wisdom and wonder. We turn together toward the light. And that helps us create islands of sanity in a world that is losing its mind.

Brian McLaren 


Gaslighting

Gaslighting is the attempt by someone to confuse a person’s perception of reality, an attempt to get them to question their memory and self-perception. Gaslighting confuses, distorts, and scrambles. It deceives. When done with mean-spiritedness, it intimidates and alienates. And creates fear.

Scot McKnight

Einstein said that “Imagination is more important than knowledge. Knowledge is limited. Imagination? encircles the world.”

The Gaze of Jesus
“The Lord turned and looked straight at Peter. Then Peter remembered the word the Lord had spoken to him: “Before the rooster crows today, you will disown me three times.””
Luke 22:61 
— What you see in the face of Jesus as he looked at Peter is the image you have of God.—
Anger? Disappointment? Love? Forgiveness?

Jonathan Storment


ARCHIE UPDATE

Mimi Report: (3-29-25)
Mr Archie is now 6# 1 oz. He is successfully taking bottle and breast. Hopefully he will come off high-flow oxygen and move wall oxygen soon.
He continues to amaze us.

So thankful

STILL ON THE JOURNEY

Tyranny – Yes, But…

‘Jesus said to them, “The kings of the Gentiles lord it over them; and those who exercise authority over them call themselves Benefactors. But you are not to be like that. Instead, the greatest among you should be like the youngest, and the one who rules like the one who serves. Luke 22:25-26

Recent conversations and further pondering about tyranny have delayed writing a cost/benefit analysis of tyranny. Maybe next time.

Conclusions regarding Luke22:25-26:

  • When Jesus says “…kings of the Gentiles lord it over them…” he is describing tyranny :cruel, unreasonable, or arbitrary use of power or control.
  • Jesus is unequivocal about what that means for his disciples —you are not to be like that. Full stop!
  • The only alternative Jesus presents is :…”the greatest among you should be like be like the youngest, and the one who rules like the one who serves”…

I am not a Biblical scholar and a proper exegesis of the passage could very well alter my understanding. I welcome any input. Until then, I continue to preach the “truth”. Tyranny is not an option for Christ followers. Our only option is Jesus’ way: …be like the youngest, and the one who rules like the one who serves“; which, for me, requires more understanding.

In recent conversation with several men, I had the opportunity to “preach”, asserting much of what I wrote in this POST about tyranny.
Recalling the conversation, I stated without qualification “lord it over” is not an option for Christ followers.
Responses came quickly. No one voiced objection to “lord it over” not being an option. What I heard was —YES, but..

In a society (church) where men assume authority, power and control is a birthright, if not a requirement to be a man; excluding “lord it over” is incomprehensible.
Christians’ (not just men) mitigation of Jesus’ “…you are not to be like that…” reveals the leverage principalities and powers have on our lives. Choosing power and control is the default for tyrants.

What I heard was not surprising. The “but’s”1 BUT- except, excepting, besides, beside, other than, except for, excluding, saving, bar, outside, apart from, barring, save, exclusive of, outside of, aside from were familiar, echoing my own sentiments when wrestling with no lording it over. Disagreement was encouraging , only wrestling with Jesus will reveal truth and show us the way.

Yes Jesus … not so among us … BUT…

My knee-jerk response is.. We are not Jesus

“There is worldly power, which Jesus eschewed, but there is also a holy power, brought by the Spirit.”2The Scandal of Leadership: Unmasking the Powers of Domination in the Church by JR Woodward

Jesus’s acts with power in the gospels. Jesus doesn’t just empathize with people, he heals them, power flows out of him. Jesus also calms storms and multiplies loaves and fishes. Jesus loves, yes, but he also has power. And yes, the Son dies in solidarity with victims on the cross, but the Father raises the Son in the power of the Holy Spirit, thereby defeating the powers of sin and death.

Yes Jesus exercised power. however, conflating Jesus’ use of power with our use of power blasphemes the unfathomable mystery of an omnipotent God.
God’s omnipotence (divine power) is problematic, full of controversy; a gateway to theodicy, problems of suffering, pain, and evil. Combined with prevailing skepticism that power corrupts, and absolute power corrupts absolutely; any notion of using Jesus as an example to justify “lording over” makes no sense.

God does not exercise top-down power and control from on high. God doesn’t “lord over” the world. The power of God works in the opposite direction, from the bottom-up. God’s power is the power of the cross, the power of weakness and powerlessness, the power of loving servanthood and self-giving. 3Richard Beck

We quite simply don’t have the power to follow any gospel ideal—such as loving others, forgiving enemies, living simply and nonviolently, or humble use of power—except in and through union with God. 4 Richard Rohr

In other words, it is OK to “lord it over” if it’s done in love.
I believe everything is to be done in love.
Follow God’s example, therefore, as dearly loved children and walk in the way of love, just as Christ loved us and gave himself up for us as a fragrant offering and sacrifice to God. Eph. 5:1-2
But.. “Lording over” in love is a non sequitur.
“lording over” is an unholy power — the spirituality of principalities and powers— Because of its nefarious nature it cannot be done in love.

To “lord over” in love is a euphemism for being likable. In each context 5My name is George – I am a tyrant. 
> Taught at home and church to be a man. 
> Indoctrinated by Ford Motor Company to be a manager. 
> Appointed deacon and elder in the church. 
where abusive power and control yielded damage, the remedy was not to abandon “lording over” but to become a benevolent tyrant.
No one seemed to expect me not to be a tyrant, they just wanted me to be nicer.
As Jesus said ” …those who exercise authority over them call themselves Benefactors.” If he looks like.. acts like.. walks like.. talks like… leads like a tyrant.. he’s a tyrant. No amount of perfume will remove evil, you only smell better.
“…each of us will either follow the scandalous way Jesus led or become a scandal. There is no neutral ground.” 6The Scandal of Leadership: Unmasking the Powers of Domination in the Church by JR Woodward

“..you are not to be like that.”

Frustration with circumstances in need of correction generates the impulse to take charge. Believing Jesus’ way to be weak and ineffectual, woke; it is clear — someone has to take charge, something must be done. The only option is to assume power and take control.
Jesus’ “not so among you” is equivalent to “It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle than for someone who is rich to enter the kingdom of God” and is as shocking today as then for his disciples.

Jesus’ answer is the same today as it was then: “With man this is impossible, but not with God; all things are possible with God.”


God reigns and rules through an invasion of love.
And if God’s power ever looked otherwise, or to expect something otherwise, it wouldn’t be the God revealed to us in Jesus Christ. True, in the face of suffering we might want a different sort of God, and that’s fine, we can refuse to confess Jesus as Lord and say that we’d rather God set the world to rights by something other than love.
We can worship some other vision of power, some other God, Lord or Kingdom.

Richard Beck

STILL ON THE JOURNEY

  • 1
    BUT- except, excepting, besides, beside, other than, except for, excluding, saving, bar, outside, apart from, barring, save, exclusive of, outside of, aside from
  • 2
    The Scandal of Leadership: Unmasking the Powers of Domination in the Church by JR Woodward
  • 3
    Richard Beck
  • 4
    Richard Rohr
  • 5
    My name is George – I am a tyrant. 
    > Taught at home and church to be a man. 
    > Indoctrinated by Ford Motor Company to be a manager. 
    > Appointed deacon and elder in the church. 
  • 6
    The Scandal of Leadership: Unmasking the Powers of Domination in the Church by JR Woodward