Menu Close

Means to an End

My previous post focused primarily on the weapon currently used by combatants to achieve their desired end, “The Sky is Falling” , aka, fear-mongering. 
Hopefully readers recognized “TSIF” as a go-to tool in broader contexts. On a personal level, my ability to employ “TSIF” served me well in various leadership contexts. Although “TSIF”  has potential for negative outcomes, it always produces results, justifying its frequent use. 
I am confident there are circumstances where “TSIF” is the only reasonable alternative. Some occasions may be so egregious they inherently produce a reflexive “TSIF” decision. In other circumstances where the desired end requires less urgent obedience or compliance “TSIF” works well but is overkill with potential for negative consequences.

Engaging “TSIF” has created an iceberg of issues and questions, of which “TSIF” is only the tip.
In thinking about “TSIF”, it occurs to me that what we are really talking about is motivation. MotivatIng people is the underlying issue. The challenge of motivating others is ubiquitous. Whether you are a CEO, pastor, principle, coach, politician, doctor, et al, whose success/survival is dependent upon motivating people; or, spouse, parent, relative, friend or neighbor, motivating others is essential to navigating daily life.

Despite virtually an infinite amount of material on human motivation, I want to share some thoughts from my many failures and few successes in motivating people.

Begin with the end in mind. (Steven Covey’s Habit #2 from “7 Habits of Highly Effective People”) Though Covey is not directly speaking to motivation, his advice is broadly applicable. With motivation, it is important to understand what end we have in mind.For this conversation, motivation has two connotations.

First, and most common and misguided is motivation misunderstood as movement. Compliance, obedience, relocation are its desired end; Transactional in it nature, it requires no agreement, commitment or internal change.

Second, motivation properly understood is transformation. The desired end is changed beliefs, agreement, commitment, loyalty, faithfulness, love. Motivation requires profoundly different skills and tools than movement.

To the point of Covey’s advice, “Begin with the end in mind”, when we want to motivate people we should start with the end in mind.

For example, parent’s fundamental challenge is motivating their children. Most parents begin with the end in mind, a dream of their children maturing into responsible adults (whatever that entails). Particularly in the early years, movement, compliance, obedience are necessary priorities. Of course there are deeper concerns but, if children don’t survive nothing else matters.

As a father, I held an inherited misconception that movement, compliance, obedience were primary objectives in raising children. Accordingly, motivation(?) of my children relied on a “TSIF” strategy.
( I suspect my inherited misconception had its origin in misguided application of “Train up a child in the way he should go: and when he is old, he will not depart from it.” Proverbs 22:6, but that’s another post)

Because a “TSIF” strategy always produces results, and I was successful in its application, ( there were some notable exceptions, that is also another post) I was deceived into thinking movement, compliance, obedience were clear indicators of successful parenting. I do not want to leave an impression that my strategy was all “bad”, it was the best tool for the end I had in mind.

The problem was, somewhere along the way, I lost sight of the end I envisioned and settled for a lesser end. Certainly, there are worst things than having responsible, compliant, obedient children and if that is the end you have in mind, by all means “TSIF” is the tool for you.

On the others hand, if the end you have in mind is mature, fully human adults, the means to that end are a different matter. That end requires motivation…a willfulness that transcends obedience and compliance, it comes from within, it is transforming; producing passion, resolve, courage, endurance.

The idea we can motivate our children, or anyone else, to become the end we have in mind, Is misguided. It is my belief that we cannot motivate our children, or anyone else, we can only produce movement. I would rephrase “How do I motivate my children to be good?” to “How can I live (parent) in such a way that my children will become motivated to be good?”

Motivation, in the proper sense, provides equal opportunity for good or evil. Just because someone is motivated doesn’t mean they will be good people.
Motivation, properly understood, resides in the realm of the transcendent, immune to transactional strategies. Accordingly, any answer to “How can I Live in such a way that my children will be motivated for good?” must find its source in the transcendent, not just any transcendence but goodness.

It should come as no surprise where I’m headed. The short answer to “How can I live (parent) in such a way that my children will be motivated for good?” is …live a life defined and shaped by love. Not the trite and shallow love we speak of so flippantly but a “…love love too deep for words, a gift not given by humans, but by God’s grace.” A love, when received, creates a heart that understands … People ultimately want love, not answers. Answers are not the capstone; love is. Most can do without specific explanations. No one can do without love.

I am deeply proud of our children. They are responsible adults and each is engaged in their own struggle to flourish as a human being. If there has been any meaningful contribution on my part, it comes through God’s gracious love for me. Love truly covers a multitude of sins.

Our secular, disenchanted culture, recognizing no need to look beyond ourselves for solutions, resists any impulse to accept transcendence as a path to human flourishing,. In contrast, love necessary for motivation and enjoyment of a fully human experience is a transcendent reality, and cannot be achieved, but must be received.

Which path will we choose?





Old Man Thinking

I often wonder if I am an anomaly or just experiencing ordinary old man stuff. I think a lot, about a lot of different things. Sometimes my mind doesn’t seem to ever take a break. It is like a kaleidoscope, patterns and colors constantly changing. Maybe that’s why I blog, writing seems to at least change the scene. It is hard to discern what is normal. I’m pretty sure I’m not completely normal but whether I’m crazy is up for grabs.

I find some comfort in this quote: “Ignorance can be educated. Crazy can be medicated… But there is no cure for stupid.” There is hope. You can watch this video to get an idea what’s going on in my head.

By the way, here is a parable I’ve been thinking about.

A brother was restless in the community and often moved to anger. So he said: “I will go and live somewhere by myself. And since I shall be able to talk or listen to no one, I shall be tranquil, and my passionate anger will cease.” He went out and lived alone in a cave. But one day he filled his jug with water and put it on the ground. It happened suddenly to fall over. He filled it again, and again it fell. And this happened a third time. And in a rage he snatched up the jug and broke it. Returning to his right mind, he knew that the demon of anger had mocked him, and he said: “Here am I by myself, and he has beaten me. I will return to the community. Wherever you live, you need effort and patience and above all God’s help.” And he rose up, and went back. (parable via R Rohr)

The Sky is Falling

This old man thinks a lot about our fractured, polarized, angry and, in my opinion, deteriorating society. Beyond political arenas, there seems to be no segment of our society exempt from the consequences of an undefined human virus of epidemic proportions which is spreading unimpeded.

The preponderance of effort by all parties is directed at the destruction of an opposing position/narrative, no matter what the cost. A few informed and intelligent people strive to identify underlying causes, but their voices are akin to stewards on the sinking Titanic telling panicked passengers to “be calm, everything will be ok”.

I am confident the lens history will reveal what is Imperceptible today. Prospects of a “lessons learned” debrief brings little comfort. With decreasing optimism of having the opportunity for hindsight, I have chosen to identify weapons being employed in this battle to the death. Perhaps if we can understand the combatants’ weapons they can be disarmed and progress toward peaceful co-existence can begin. (Assuming no infringement on the 2nd Amendment, of course)

Most recently, it occurred to me “the sky is falling” is the weapon of choice for both sides. If you are unfamiliar with the story of Chicken Little, you can read it HERE.

“The sky is falling” is a euphemism for fear-mongering .

Fearmongering or scaremongering is the spreading of frightening and exaggerated rumors of an impending danger or the habit or tactic of purposely and needlessly arousing public fear about an issue. Fear-mongering – whether justified or not – can sometimes elicit a societal response called Chicken Little syndrome, described as “inferring catastrophic conclusions possibly resulting in paralysis”. It has also been defined as “a sense of despair or passivity which blocks the audience from actions”. The term began appearing in the 1950s and the phenomenon has been noted in many different societal contexts. (Wikipedia)

Although, fear-mongering, as defined, is reprehensible to any reasoned person, I find it amazingly ironic that utilization of “the sky is falling” is ubiquitous. Not particularly surprising In a culture that assumes people are effectively and efficiently motivated by fear. Leadership in families, churches, companies, government and organizations regularly, if not intuitively, resort to “the sky is falling”.

The subject is complicated by the reality, in some cases, “the sky is falling” is absolutely required. If there is a tornado, avalanche or similar imminent hreat, to not assert “the sky is falling” may well be criminal. On the other hand, to assert falsely “the sky is falling”, i.e., “fire” in a crowded theatre is criminal.

In my opinion, both sides are screaming “the sky is falling”, feeling justified by deeply held beliefs that the sky, is, in deed, falling. I hold little hope of compromise or conversion.

A few thoughts about choosing “the sky is falling”.

  • Even with a “clear and present danger” real risk of unintended collateral damage exists.
  • People who believe “the sky is falling” often suspend good judgement and common sense.
  • “the sky is falling” produces results
  • “the sky is falling” creates movement but it doesn’t change people.
  • Panicked groups cannot be controlled.

The pressing question for me is, how should I respond to “the sky is falling”? Chicken LittlE is helpful.

  • When encountering an unexplained and/or unanticipated threat (acorn), resist knee-jerk assumptions. Gather facts necessary to determine the magnitude of danger.
  • Seek reliable counsel for confirmation and appropriate action.
  • Only when confident of the reality and magnitude of threat, and, having clarity necessary for a response, should you alert others.
  • When fearful We are most vulnerable to seduction we would never consider otherwise.
  • Resist the temptation think the worst.

Doing some cursory research on “the sky is falling” i.e. Chicken Little story, I came across some interesting insights.

The moral to be drawn changes, depending on the version. Where there is a “happy ending”, the moral is not to be a “Chicken” but to have courage. In other versions where the birds are eaten by the fox, the fable is interpreted as a warning not to believe everything one is told.

A very early example containing the basic motif and many of the elements of the tale is some 25 centuries old and appears in the Buddhist scriptures.  the Buddha, upon hearing about some particular religious practices, comments that there is no special merit in them, but rather that they are “like the noise the hare heard.” He then tells the story of a hare disturbed by a falling fruit who believes that the earth is coming to an end. The hare starts a stampede among the other animals until a lion halts them, investigates the cause of the panic and restores calm. The fable teaches the necessity for deductive reasoning and subsequent investigation.

We need a lion.

Intersections – Salvation (2)

This post continues a series entitled intersections. As I reflect on my life’s journey, various intersections along the way come to mind. My ambition was for a straight and narrow path. but, that’s not how life goes.

As indicated by the title, this post is the second of two. If you have not read them first, you should do so. Click HERE to read.

In my previous post my salvation journey was described as amovement from “YES,but” to “YES”. In this post, I hope to flesh out the space between “YES,but” and “YES”.

Before addressing the space between, let me say that both “YES” are the same but very different. Each is a declaration that I am saved by the grace of God through Jesus the Christ. Perhaps that paradox is analogous to my marriage. At the conclusion of our vows 57 years ago; I could answer, Are you married? YES. Asked the that question today, my answer would be the same YES. I think you can understand how different the two “YES” are.

To fill the space between “YES,but” and “YES” I think it’s helpful to use the metaphor of “middle tint” I introduced in an earlier post. The source document is available HERE.

The landscape between “YES,but” and “YES” requires middle tint to assure an observer’s eyes are drawn to most important subject of the painting, salvation through Jesus Christ. Without middle tint any painting will be dull and flat, and lose it’s potential for dramatic impact.

The work of painting the expanse between my baptism and today has not been my mine but the hand of God working in my life. A work not yet complete.

LoadIng her brush with color from the palette of God’s word, the Holy Spirit began to slowly but surely, build the middle tint of my landscape. With each stroke, salvation came into sharper relief, creating a more beautiful and profound image. First came the startling hues of grace, followed by the deep shades of incarnation, simultaneously blended with the tertiary color of Jesus’ life and teaching. Inevitably came the sharp hues of sanctification, soften by the reassuring tint of the Kingdom of God.

For me, the depths of salvation have not been plumbed but the transactional nature of salvation at my baptism has been transformed by God’s work as we have walked together these 50+ years. The following thoughts of Jason Zahariades express well the result of my transformation.

Salvation is the process of restoration to what humans were created to be. Rather than sin being the breaking of God’s Law, the root of sin is the movement from being to non-being. Sin is the distortion of our humanity, of who we are supposed to be as God’s image on earth. Rather than being truly human, sin makes us subhuman. So the problem of sin is much deadlier and sinister than mere guilt or disobedience. It is the warping, distortion and brokenness of who we are as human beings. It is the full corruption of my mind, heart, body, soul and relationships. In this light, I don’t just need to be forgiven. I need to be healed. I don’t just need assurance of admittance into heaven in the future. I need assurance that who I am in the present is being transformed out of my desperate and destructive subhuman existence and into the image and likeness of God as I was divinely intended to live.

So salvation isn’t primarily about guilt and forgiveness. It’s about brokenness and healing. It’s about delusion and illumination. It’s about distortion and transformation. It’s about death and life in the here and now. As a follower of Jesus, I truly cannot say, “I am saved.” I can only say, “I am being saved.”

Jason Zahariades

The truth is that every theological system that allots to man some responsibility in the saving of his own soul inevitably ends up by making man his own savior.(Unknown)